Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Jazz Assumptions

                I didn’t have many assumptions about jazz coming into Black Studies 14. I had played jazz trumpet in middle school and knew who musicians like Louis Armstrong, John Coltrane, and Miles Davis were. But as far as my jazz education went, that was it. After taking this course, however, I realize how much I really didn’t know. I was ignorant to jazz’s history and stylistic diversity, as well as the huge socioeconomic impact it had on America, especially regarding race relations between Blacks and whites.
To me, jazz was a singular musical genre. Having played mostly swing and big band styles in school, I always assumed that that was what jazz was supposed to sound like. I hadn’t really been exposed to the “breakneck speed (Davis 70)” of bebop, or the slow, languid tones of blues. In fact, I was even unaware that jazz was not just one cohesive style. Swing and jazz were interchangeable terms. After hearing the likes of Lead Belly, Benny Goodman, and Charlie Parker, I finally recognized that jazz was a broad genre that consisted of many substyles that evolved over time.
The key revelation from this class was about the impact that jazz had on American society in regards to race. I hadn’t even realized that jazz was a Black art form, despite the fact that most of the jazz musicians I knew were Black. By examining it in a new perspective, this class showed how integral jazz was in changing the racial dynamic that proliferated America. It exemplified the potential for Black excellence, and forced the uncomfortable conversation about why Blacks were seen as inherently inferior in a white-dominated society. Even Miles Davis, a genius in his own right, was impacted by racist thinking. At Julliard, he had a white teacher that explained “that the reason black people played the blues was because they were poor and had to pick cotton. They were sad and that's where the blues came from, their sadness (Davis 59).” Jazz and its musicians confronted stereotypes and oversimplifications like this and showed that being Black in a racial society was far more complex than previously thought.
Through this class, I was able to gain a better understanding of not only what jazz was, but also what it meant. Apart from simply being a popular style of music, jazz played a key part in righting some of the racial wrongs that plagued American society. It not only shed light on the prejudices and discrimination that affected Blacks, but also showed that they had the agency to change their social, political and economic standing. Jazz was a valuable instrument that helped shape race relations in America, and its effects can be felt even today.

Commented on Steenalisa Tilcock

“I thought you did a good job of summarizing some of the facts we learned about jazz from the class, as well as some of the racial implications that went along with it. I think the question you asked regarding bebop and white influence is a very good one and something that I hope we get to discuss in class.”

Friday, March 6, 2015

Jazz and Community

Economic opportunity is often cited as the catalyst for jazz cropping up in various cities like Chicago and New York. However, jazz was not simply chasing the money. For places like San Juan Hill and Leimart Park, jazz grew organically out of the communities that existed there. It was a bonding agent that brought the community together, even in times of conflict. For these places, community created jazz, but jazz also fostered community.
                San Juan Hill “had earned the dubious distinction of being one of the ‘busiest crime areas in New York City.’ (Kelley 19)” This violence was the result of clashes between different ethnic groups and resulted in several race riots. Despite the violence, however, there was still a “strong sense of community (Kelley 20)” in San Juan Hill. Music flourished, where “every household had an instrument (Kelley 21).” There were also block parties on West 63rd Street where diverse types of music were played (Kelley 24). This environment allowed for the exchange of cultures, and softened some of the tensions in the community. Despite previous conflicts, Southern and Caribbean black cultures started meshing, where “virtually every kid became a kind of cultural hybrid (Kelley 24).” With so much ethnic discord in San Juan Hill, music was a way for people to come together and create harmony in a hostile environment. Thelonious Monk’s legacy was greatly influenced by his time there. His experiences living in a racially diverse environment, as well as at various institutions, helped shape his musical style. He was exposed to Caribbean styles, and places like the Columbus Hill Neighborhood and his church (Kelley 26) all helped foster his genius. His success shows how some of the troubles that defined San Juan Hill life were able to be offset by the sense of community that music helped create.
                Leimart Park has a similar story to San Juan Hill. There was great racial tension in the area that erupted into violence during the 1992 Los Angeles race riots. These riots had a profound impact on Leimart Park. People saw the conflict and looked for ways to solve it. Like with San Juan Hill, music was an integral part to dissolving some of the tensions. Residents of Leimart Park used music, and specifically jazz, as a way to bring people together and talk to each other. It allowed people to examine the aspects of their community that they didn’t like, and debate the ways to make it better. Herein lies the biggest difference between Leimart Park and San Juan Hill. At San Juan Hill, the community that arose out of the violence and discord was an unconscious one. Music was simply a common denominator that brought people together. In Leimart Park, jazz was used proactively as a way to generate discussion and combat the tensions that existed. It encouraged people to talk about the problems and look for solutions. This contrast of passive and active exemplifies how music can be used to affect community.

                It is important to examine the relationship between jazz and its community. For many places, the line between the two has been blurred. Jazz is Leimart Park, and Leimart Park is jazz. Jazz is San Juan Hill, and San Juan Hill is jazz. For these two communities, music had become part of their cultural consciousness. It shaped how they perceive the world, and how they express themselves through their music. In many ways, this phenomenon brings jazz back full circle. Like its African ancestors, jazz had become a keystone in its participants’ identity.

Commented on Steenalisa Tilcock

Thursday, February 12, 2015

Racial Tension in Jazz
                Jazz has historically been known as a predominantly Black art form. From its infancy to its heyday in the 1930s, many of its greatest stars have been Black. Despite this fact, however, jazz has been the center of a very curious racial paradox. Jazz was a product of Black culture, yet it rose in popularity largely by catering to white audiences.  As a result, there has always been an underlying tension that whites were able to enjoy the fruits of Jazz, while simultaneously discriminating against its founders. This tension was finally brought to the forefront during the 1930s when jazz’s increasing popularity gave it a platform to start confronting some of the racial issues that had been plaguing it from its conception.
                The racial divide between Blacks and whites has been a huge, and unfortunate, part of American history. A product of slavery, the idea of Black inferiority had become commonplace in America. There was a pervasive idea that Blacks were inherently simpler, stupider, and less deserving of respect than their white counterparts. Even when slavery was abolished, Blacks were still subject to discriminatory policies and practices, like the Jim Crow laws and segregation. As a result, Blacks suffered economically, socially, and politically. There seemed to be little that could be done to alter this racist mindset, until the inevitable rise of jazz. Black legends like Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington, King Oliver, and Fletcher Henderson captivated white audiences, and thrust a Black art form into what had been an almost exclusively white popular culture. This surprised many whites, exemplified by Charlie Black, who commented that “’it is impossible to overstate the significance of a sixteen-year-old southern boy’s seeing genius, for the first time, in a black (Jazz: A History of America’s Music 1-2).’” This increasing exposure to the potential of Black talent led to a very uncomfortable contradiction. It was no longer possible to maintain the idea of Black inferiority when more and more evidence of Black genius was being broadcast on radios and played in music halls and clubs. How could one think Blacks were inherently worse when jazz had become the epitome of American culture? As Stowe comments, “[jazz] challenged the ironclad rigidity of Depression-era segregation, crediting blacks with unique powers of spontaneous artistic creativity, among other things (53).” With jazz reaching peak popularity in the 1930s, whites were finally forced to confront this flawed way of thinking.
                There seemed to also be an onus on successful Black musicians to use their fortune to help better the condition of all Blacks. In fact, John Hammond had criticized Duke Ellington that he “shuts his eyes to the abuses being heaped upon his race and his original class (Swing Changes 51).” While it may have helped had Ellington used his fame to actively champion Black rights, it was an unfair expectation for him to bite the hand that feeds him, especially if that hand belonged to a powerful and violent mob boss. Instead, by sparking the realization that—as obvious as it sounds—Blacks were people that deserved dignity, he was able to be a catalyst that brought the race conversation into public discourse. This discussion would ultimately lead to the civil rights movement that is continuing to shape race relations even today.

Commented on Chase Racich

I thought you did a good job of bringing in a lot of examples and concrete details about how racism had an impact on jazz. The only thing was I think you could have expanded on the last paragraph and described how the increasing awareness of unfairness helped shape jazz and race relations as a whole.

Friday, February 6, 2015

The Chicago Jazz Age
                Chicago and New York both played an integral role in the rise of the jazz age in the 1920s. Some of the most important figures in jazz history hailed from these two cities, and it was there that jazz really grew and evolved into a more comprehensive and complex musical genre. While both cities were influential in the growth of jazz, Chicago really stands out as the driving force behind its popularization in the 1920s.
                The initial—and possibly most important—draw of Chicago was its potential for greater economic benefit, where “sidemen in Chicago bands could earn $40 per week or more during the years following World War I— a far cry from the $1.50 to $2.50 per engagement a New Orleans player might have commanded during that era (Gioia 72).” Musicians flocked to Chicago to take advantage of this promise for financial security, making it into one of the greatest hotspots of jazz talent.
While there was still racism in Chicago, the nightclubs were not as heavily segregated as they were in New York. They did not have a whites-only policy, but still had some kinds of Jim Crow-style seating policies (Travis 43). Even with more blacks participating in the jazz scene, however, there was still an interesting paradox. Jazz, a largely black cultural product that was largely performed by black musicians, was still being consumed largely by white audiences. This peculiarity led to accusations that whites were appropriating black culture, accusations that only got louder with the rise in prominence of white musicians like Bix Beiderbecke and the Austin High School Gang. However, this phenomenon of white affection towards jazz could be seen in a more positive light. As the hegemonic cultural group of America, whites’ tastes were oftentimes America’s tastes as well. As a result, this white affection allowed jazz to break into mainstream culture and prevented it from being confined to simply being another niche genre on a greater American musical palette.
Chicago eventually developed into its own form of jazz. It seemed at times to struggle with its identity, even described as “schizophrenia set to music (“The Chicagoans” 161). It did diverge from previous forms of jazz, however. Before, jazz had all been about being part of the collective band, being another cog in the machine. In Chicago, it was about the soloist. The emphasis of the individual allowed for more complex ensembles, as well as more improvisation because these single players had greater discretion to exercise their creative skills (lecture). Prominent musicians like Louis Armstrong and Bix Beiderbecke epitomized this idea that eventually became an identifying feature of Chicago jazz.
It is undeniable that New York had a significant impact on the growth of jazz as a genre. James P. Johnson and his innovation of the stride piano would be influential in the eventual development of swing (lecture). Ellington, Henderson, and Waller all made great contributions towards popularizing jazz. At the end of the day, however, Chicago has proven that its influence has been greater, if for no other reason that it rose to prominence first. Many of the musicians that left New Orleans as part of the diaspora—including Jelly Roll Morton, the man who first thought of jazz abstractly—ended up in Chicago. As a result, some of the advancements in jazz that occurred in Chicago ended up directly benefiting later New York musicians. For example, Louis Armstrong was credited for essentially showing Fletcher Henderson’s band how to swing (“Fletcher Henderson” 109). As the big brother of the 1920s, Chicago was the leader for popularizing jazz.


 Commented on Darian Fathi
I thought you did a really good job at answering all aspects of the prompt. You provided good concrete examples supporting your thesis. The only thing I would recommend is possibly doing what Professor Stewart was talking about in class and giving some of the antithesis and refuting it.

Thursday, January 22, 2015

David Wang Blog #1 New Orleans Jazz

Jazz, as an art form, is an amalgamation of various distinct cultures. When listening to it, one can hear tinges of African, European, and Latin influences. Therefore, it would only make sense that jazz found its roots in New Orleans, one of the greatest melting pots in the United States. Situated at the base of the Mississippi River, New Orleans was a huge trading city that was also the cosmopolitan center of the South (Lecture). As a result, New Orleans had a kind of ethnic diversity unlike anywhere else in America. This diversity of people and cultures a crucial aspect of New Orleans that allowed for the syncretism necessary to breed new music forms like blues, ragtime, and eventually, jazz.

Jazz shows many signs of African influences. The characteristic of African impact is jazz’s use of rich rhythmic content (Gioia 9). African music relies heavily on the use of drums and percussion to produce music, and jazz does as well. Another key aspect of jazz that mimics its African ancestor is the importance of improvisation (Gioia 9). Much of western music at that time depended on prewritten music, and improvisation is what helped defined jazz as a distinct art form. Furthermore, there was a significant Mexican contribution to the rise of jazz. In 1884, Mexico sent a military band to the Cotton Exposition in New Orleans (Johnson 225). Some of the musicians ended up staying and became influential actors in the rise of jazz. Lorenzo ‘Papa’ Tio was an accomplished clarinetist that taught his craft to many aspiring jazz musicians, at least 15 of whom went on to become professionals (Johnson 226). Also, Florencio Ramos was another musician that was credited with bringing the saxophone, the instrument most commonly associated with jazz in modern times, to New Orleans (Johnson 229).

It is undeniable that New Orleans’ appreciation for music was also integral to the rise of jazz. Gioia comments that “the birth of this music would have been unthinkable without the extraordinary local passion for brass bands, an enthusiasm that lay at the core of that city’s relationship to the musical arts (31).” This appreciation for music was necessary to drive innovation and development. New Orleans’ penchant for celebration provided the necessary breeding grounds for jazz to flourish by giving performers and others a place to play and an audience to play for. Without it, influential musicians like Jelly Roll Morton, Joe “King” Oliver, and Louis Armstrong would not have had the platform to perfect their craft.

By combining New Orleans’ passion for music with the diverse cultural elements of its people, jazz was able to come to fruition as its own musical genre. The passion provided the drive and motivation for jazz’s development, and the cultural gumbo of New Orleans provided the necessary tools to make it happen. Without one or the other, jazz would likely not have grown into the style it is today. Jazz was one of the most prominent pieces of black culture that was brought into mainstream pop culture, and it would have not been possible had New Orleans not been the perfect environment for it to develop.

Commented on Samet