Friday, February 6, 2015

The Chicago Jazz Age
                Chicago and New York both played an integral role in the rise of the jazz age in the 1920s. Some of the most important figures in jazz history hailed from these two cities, and it was there that jazz really grew and evolved into a more comprehensive and complex musical genre. While both cities were influential in the growth of jazz, Chicago really stands out as the driving force behind its popularization in the 1920s.
                The initial—and possibly most important—draw of Chicago was its potential for greater economic benefit, where “sidemen in Chicago bands could earn $40 per week or more during the years following World War I— a far cry from the $1.50 to $2.50 per engagement a New Orleans player might have commanded during that era (Gioia 72).” Musicians flocked to Chicago to take advantage of this promise for financial security, making it into one of the greatest hotspots of jazz talent.
While there was still racism in Chicago, the nightclubs were not as heavily segregated as they were in New York. They did not have a whites-only policy, but still had some kinds of Jim Crow-style seating policies (Travis 43). Even with more blacks participating in the jazz scene, however, there was still an interesting paradox. Jazz, a largely black cultural product that was largely performed by black musicians, was still being consumed largely by white audiences. This peculiarity led to accusations that whites were appropriating black culture, accusations that only got louder with the rise in prominence of white musicians like Bix Beiderbecke and the Austin High School Gang. However, this phenomenon of white affection towards jazz could be seen in a more positive light. As the hegemonic cultural group of America, whites’ tastes were oftentimes America’s tastes as well. As a result, this white affection allowed jazz to break into mainstream culture and prevented it from being confined to simply being another niche genre on a greater American musical palette.
Chicago eventually developed into its own form of jazz. It seemed at times to struggle with its identity, even described as “schizophrenia set to music (“The Chicagoans” 161). It did diverge from previous forms of jazz, however. Before, jazz had all been about being part of the collective band, being another cog in the machine. In Chicago, it was about the soloist. The emphasis of the individual allowed for more complex ensembles, as well as more improvisation because these single players had greater discretion to exercise their creative skills (lecture). Prominent musicians like Louis Armstrong and Bix Beiderbecke epitomized this idea that eventually became an identifying feature of Chicago jazz.
It is undeniable that New York had a significant impact on the growth of jazz as a genre. James P. Johnson and his innovation of the stride piano would be influential in the eventual development of swing (lecture). Ellington, Henderson, and Waller all made great contributions towards popularizing jazz. At the end of the day, however, Chicago has proven that its influence has been greater, if for no other reason that it rose to prominence first. Many of the musicians that left New Orleans as part of the diaspora—including Jelly Roll Morton, the man who first thought of jazz abstractly—ended up in Chicago. As a result, some of the advancements in jazz that occurred in Chicago ended up directly benefiting later New York musicians. For example, Louis Armstrong was credited for essentially showing Fletcher Henderson’s band how to swing (“Fletcher Henderson” 109). As the big brother of the 1920s, Chicago was the leader for popularizing jazz.


 Commented on Darian Fathi
I thought you did a really good job at answering all aspects of the prompt. You provided good concrete examples supporting your thesis. The only thing I would recommend is possibly doing what Professor Stewart was talking about in class and giving some of the antithesis and refuting it.

No comments:

Post a Comment